Beating the Algorithm without a Marketing Department
Beating the Algorithm without a marketing department
BOTR: Club ops 101 series
Editor’s Note — Behind the Scenes of Clubland
This article marks the third article in our Club Ops 101 series taking an honest look at the off the field realities of running a grassroots rugby club. The series aims to pull back the curtain on what it actually takes to run a rugby club. The goal isn’t to criticize or overwhelm, but to share lessons learned, spark better conversations, and help clubs build systems that are sustainable for the long haul.
Most grassroots rugby clubs don’t have the luxury of a marketing department. We don’t have interns scheduling posts in the content calendar, advertising agencies testing engagement funnels, and we definitely don’t have budgets to “boost” every post that falls flat.
What we have is a cracked clubhouse door, beat up equipment, a muddy pitch, and a 19-year-old winger who somehow knows exactly what song is trending this week.
And that’s enough.
Here’s the truth that no one tells us. Social media algorithms aren’t built for us. It’s built for brands, influencers, and professional teams with media crews.
Fortunately, grassroots rugby has something the algorithm can’t manufacture. We have authenticity along with a heavy dose of personality, a little chaos, and a community that loves all of it.
Hacking the system is possible. There are clubs out there absolutely killing it while pulling millions of views. I’m telling you that it isn’t as far-fetched as you may think. It won’t happen overnight, but with consistency and the right approach it can happen.
So, instead of burning up your limited marketing funds trying to buy engagement, make use of your strengths.
Here’s how.
1. Hand the Mic to the Young Players
If your social media is being run by the same three committee members who’ve been running it since 2014… we need to talk.
You don’t need to give up control, but you do need to give up some space. Provide some clear direction so that your club messaging is consistent with your mission. After that, let go.
Find two or three younger players who:
- Already create content – most of them are already doing on their personal accounts
- Understand trends before you do
- Aren’t afraid to be on camera and genuine
Make them your “content captains.”
Let them:
- Film matchday arrival clips
- Post locker room (appropriate, of course) moments
- Jump on trending sounds
- Run post-match Instagram stories
The algorithm rewards familiarity with platform behavior. Your 20-year-olds live there. Let them cook.
2. Stop Posting Like a Press Release
I’ll be the first to say that I am 100% guilty of this. I have been writing match reports since before social media existed. Even my text messages have the correct punctuation and grammar.
Nobody logs onto Instagram hoping to read a match report. That’s why club websites exist.
Social media needs:
- Emotion
- Tension
- Personality
- Humor
- Conflict
- Community
Instead of reporting the score, show the muddy prop who is covered in mud with smiles all around.
Show your captain’s pre-game speech.
Capture the 2nd XV celebrating a win over a rival like they won a World Cup.
Give some love to your match day chefs cooking up a feast.
Tell genuine stories. Don’t be afraid to show the messy side of grassroots rugby.
3. Short > Perfect
You do not need cinematic drone footage cut like a Michael Bay film.
You need:
- 7–15 second clips
- Raw sideline reactions
- Quick try celebrations
- One-liner interviews
The algorithm loves:
- Reels
- Vertical videos
- Native platform editing
- Captions burned into the screen
There has been a significant shift towards short form video, reels, etc. in the last year or so. They are where it is at. Well, at least for the time being.
Heck, even the number of followers you have doesn’t have the same impact as it did in the past. Almost 75% of the views for the Bottom of the Ruck social Instagram comes from non-followers. The bulk of those come through short videos.
4. Build Club Characters
Every club has them.
- A 50-year-old front rower who refuses to retire, but never refuses a pint
- An ambitious new player
- The club mom who keeps everyone in line
Turn them into recurring characters.
Give them:
- Weekly features
- Running jokes
- Spotlight posts
Algorithms reward familiarity. People like to follow real and genuine people, not logos.
5. Use “Us vs The World” Energy
Grassroots rugby already lives in this mindset. Our governing bodies aren’t throwing money at us. We’re used to making things work on a budget.
Be proud of the resiliency and ingenuity of your clubs. Lean right into it and show it off. Some of my favorite club accounts are doing just that all with a tongue in cheek style that doesn’t take itself too seriously.
Examples:
- “No cameras, No contracts, Just us.”
- “Built by volunteers.”
- “This is what real rugby looks like.”
- “Still here. Still muddy.”
Tribal energy drives engagement. Club pride drives shares. Engagement is the trigger that drives people to your clubs.
6. Post When the Emotion Is Highest
Don’t wait.
Post:
- Immediately after the final whistle
- During the social
- During training when everyone is laughing
Emotion is engagement fuel. Some of my most powerful and highly engaged social media posts have come when I let down my professional facade and spoke from the heart. Messy and real.
By Tuesday night, nobody cares about Saturday’s score. They’ve already moved on. A shaky iPhone clip posted today beats a perfectly edited highlight package posted next Thursday.
Speed wins. There is almost certainly a recency bias when it comes to the human consumption of social media.
7. Make It About the Community, Not Just the Team
The algorithm favors conversation and posts that draw in others. Collaborating with others gets your posts in front of even more people.
Tag:
- Opposing clubs
- Sponsors
- Local businesses
- Alumni
- Volunteers
- Rugby Media sites – like Bottom of the Ruck 😉
Ask questions that provoke conversation and nostalgia. Make use of a call to action to generate engagements.
Comments are currency in the social media world.
8. Consistency Beats Virality
While they are certainly great, you don’t need to have a viral post to break through the barrier.
You need:
- 3–4 consistent posts per week
- Matchday rhythm
- Training snippets
- Sponsor and Volunteer shoutouts
Algorithms reward accounts that show up consistently. Posting once every month or so won’t get you any traction. This is where having a team approach to social media is a benefit. Instead of one person carrying the load, split it up among 2-3 people.
Content needs to keep rolling in to feed the beast. Aim for 3-4 posts a week and at least one of those being a short video clip. Be consistent and you’ll notice the efforts within a few month.
9. Don’t Chase Every Trend
Yes, use trending audio.
No, you don’t need to copy every dance.
Stay aligned with your club identity. This is massively important. Don’t allow trends to change who you are as a club.
Remember, people want to see the real you. Getting in on a fun trend that aligns with your club values is a great idea. Chasing every single trend may lead to an identity crisis.
If it doesn’t feel like your club, don’t post it.
Authenticity always outperforms imitation in the long run.
10. Remember Why You’re Posting
This isn’t about vanity metrics. Likes, shares, and views eventually need conversion.
It’s about:
- Attracting new players
- Keeping your members connected
- Showing sponsors value
- Building club pride
- Showing your club off to the community
Look at every post as a recruitment tool. Not just for players, but for volunteers, supporters, and future committee members.
The Bigger Picture
The algorithm will change. It always does. The sooner that we catch onto those shifts, the quicker we can make adjustments.
Grassroots rugby survives because we adapt. We adjust and lean on each other.
We don’t need production crews.All it takes is some passion, personality, and the courage to let our clubs be seen for what they really are.
Messy. Loyal. Volunteer-built